Gitcoin Knowledge Base
EN
EN
  • Welcome to Gitcoin
  • Gitcoin DAO
    • Initiatives
      • DAO Support
    • Workstream Resources
      • Full Accounting
      • Full Snapshot History
    • FDD FAQ
      • What is a Sybil attack?
    • DAO FAQ
      • What is GitcoinDAO?
      • What is Quadratic Lands?
      • What are governance workstreams?
      • How do I get involved in governance?
      • What is the Gitcoin Stewards Delegation Program?
      • Who chooses Stewards?
      • Tell me more about Stewardship.
      • Where does governance happen?
      • What does a future Gitcoin DAO look like?
      • Will you eventually dissolve Gitcoin as a company?
  • Gitcoin Token
    • GTC FAQ
      • Why is Gitcoin launching a token?
      • What is the address of GTC?
      • What is the GTC Issuance?
      • How do I claim my token ?
      • I try to claim my tokens on mobile and it didn't work!
      • I missed the GTC token claim, what happens next?
      • Quadratic Lands Token Distribution web3 support-Delegate Voting Power
      • Quadratic Lands Token Distribution web3 support- Token Claim
      • Quadratic Lands Token Distribution web3 support- Signed Message Vote
      • What happens to my delegations if I transfer the tokens to someone else?
      • What types of things can the community govern with GTC?
      • Why don’t I have tokens?
      • What is Quadratic Lands?
      • I missed the GTC token claim, what happens next?
      • How can I check the status of my grant?
      • What are governance workstreams?
      • Who chooses Stewards?
  • Gitcoin Grants
    • What are Gitcoin Grants ?
    • Grants FAQ
      • What is the scope of Gitcoin Grants?
      • Are there any grant rules I need to follow?
      • I'm a programmer who wants to build on Gitcoin Grants, where do I start?
      • I see a grant that I don't like, what do I do?
      • I've posted a grant, how do I maximize my contributions?
      • Tell me about the technology you're using for Gitcoin grants
      • What do I do if my contributions are missing
      • What is the Gitcoin Grants Roadmap?
      • What's Quadratic Funding?
      • Why isn't the match amount updating?
      • Why should I contribute?
      • How can I withdraw my funds from zksync?
      • How much volume has Gitcoin Grants done?
      • I see a bug or I've got a question, what do I do?
      • I see a grant that is not a public good on the platform, what do I do?
      • I want to explore Gitcoin's other products, where do I go?
      • What is Gitcoin's mission?
      • Why isn't my grant active?
      • Why is Quadratic funding powerful?
      • Where can I learn more?
      • Learn more about matching rounds
      • How does one decide between the Grant contribution checkout options?
      • How do I withdraw my funds from an L2 (zkSync and/or Polygon/Matic?)
      • How do you prevent Sybil attacks?
  • Gitcoin Bounties
    • Bounties FAQ
      • How do I get started with Bounties
      • How do I submit work?
  • Gitcoin Quests
    • Quests FAQ
      • How do I mint a kudo?
      • How do I use kudos ?
      • Why can't I access my account?
  • External links
    • Moonshot Collective
  • Gitcoin Policy
    • Code of Conduct
    • Policy
      • Introduction
        • The Gitcoin Mission
        • What are we protecting ?
        • Why Quadratic Funding Through Gitcoin Grants Matters ?
        • Red Team vs Blue Team
        • Legitimacy as a North Star for Gitcoin Grants
      • Gitcoin Grants Platform and Technology
      • Governance
        • Accepting Round Results
        • Making Policy Updates
        • Subjective Decisions
        • Accepting Workstreams
        • Stewards Role
        • Credible Neutrality
      • GitcoinDAO Role in Grants
      • Collection Levels & Participation Policies
        • Ecosystem Acceptance
        • Round Acceptance
        • Sub-Round Acceptance
        • Side-Round Acceptance
      • Grant Participation Policy
        • The Grant Approval Process
        • Platform Level Grant Participation Policy
        • Ecosystem Level Grant Participation Policy
          • Side Round Ecosystem Policy Documentation
            • Ethereum Ecosystem Participation Policy (GR11, GR10, GR9, etc.)
            • GitcoinDAO Ecosystem Participation Policy
            • All Exclusive Ecosystem Policy Documentation
      • User Participation Policy
        • Round User Participation Policy
        • Ethereum Ecosystem User Participation Policy Documentation
        • Ecosystem Level User Participation Policy
        • Platform Level User Participation Policy
        • User Disputes, Sanctions, and Appeals
      • Understanding Potential Attack Vectors
        • Fraud/Impersonation
        • Collusion Attack
        • Sybil Attack
        • Bribery/Quid Pro Quo
      • Fraud Deterrent Mechanisms
        • Trustbonus
        • Identity Requirements
        • Integration to DID
        • Pairwise Bounding
        • Minimum Donation
      • Active Defense Measures
        • Sybil Detection by Machine Learning
        • Crowdsourced Flagging
        • Human Review
      • The Fraud Tax
      • Community Oversight
      • Appeals
        • Introduction to Appeals
        • Introduction to Appeals for Denied Grants.
        • Appeal Process - Stage 1
        • Appeal Process - Stage 2
Powered by GitBook
On this page

Was this helpful?

  1. Gitcoin Policy
  2. Policy
  3. Appeals

Introduction to Appeals for Denied Grants.

Big-picture introduction to Gitcoin Appeals for denied grants.

PreviousIntroduction to AppealsNextAppeal Process - Stage 1

Last updated 3 years ago

Was this helpful?

Gitcoin ensures each grant application gets a written-review by multiple members of the Fraud Detection & Defence (FDD) workstream who try to determine if a grant and its applicant are compliant with the relevant Grant Eligibility Policy. More about the FDD workstream can be found here:

See the original Grant Eligibility Policies here:

Compliant grants get recommended for inclusion in various levels of Gitcoin grant funding. Non-compliant grants get recommended for exclusion from various levels of Gitcoin grant funding. The Grant Approval Committee then considers each grant on its merits, while also noting the recommendations of the reviewers, and makes the decision to include or exclude a grant.

Unfortunately sometimes mistakes get made. This is a human-made process run by humans. Mistakes can take the form of a compliant grant getting excluded from funding or a non-compliant (or fraudulent) grant getting included for funding.

Gitcoin is committed to funding and building open source software & public goods but Gitcoin is also committed to equality, justice, credible neutrality and decentralization. To mitigate the consequences of a possible mistaken grant exclusion, Gitcoin offers an appeal process.

The appeal process is the last option available to a denied grant applicant. The appeal process is designed to be fair, objective and accessible.

https://www.notion.so/gitcoin/The-Role-of-FDD-37c350abc200487db6fa8ffc9ab98e08
https://www.notion.so/gitcoin/Gitcoin-Grants-Policy-Wiki-7ed7f7b201ba44bbb8f31d51c3a2d3d5